The Only Two Clearing Prints This Cycle Came From the Same Buyer
An index built partly on non-binding indications says the secondary market healed, while two completed acquisitions say 2021-vintage software clears at single-digit percentages of peak.
Same business, three discounts
A hypothetical $2B secondary in SambaNova, held perfectly still, prints three different ways. Against the April 2021 Series D at $5.1B: a 61% discount. Against the roughly $2.2B February Series E led by Vista Equity and Cambium: a 9% discount. Against the July 8 Series F first close at $11B post-money (General Atlantic leading, with T. Rowe Price, Capital Group, BlackRock and the Qatar Investment Authority alongside): an 82% discount. Only the denominator moved. Bloomberg had Intel near a deal at roughly $1.6 billion seven months earlier; those talks stalled.
So discount-to-last-round is not a comparable metric. It reports when a company last raised. PitchBook's Q2 report names the mechanism, with Emily Zheng noting that "companies that cannot raise on strong terms right now generally are not raising at all." Raise, and you join the zero-discount bucket by construction. Don't, and you keep your 2021 reference and live in the tail.
The tails moved; the middle did not
Forge's distribution holds the information, and both ends moved inside a month. The 90th percentile went from a 79% premium to a 27% premium, which is 52 points of AI premium gone in four weeks. The 75th fell from a 23% premium to 7%. The 10th-percentile discount widened from 50% to 57%, and the 25th sits at 34%. Barbell, not recovery. The liquidity base is thinning as sellers arrive: buy-side indications fell to 48% of new and updated interest in July from 57%, the first non-majority month since late 2023, still well above the sub-40% trough of 2022.
Bending Spoons is the price-setter nobody underwrote
Both prints that actually cleared came from one buyer. On August 4, Bending Spoons agreed to take Airtable at an estimated $2.25B equity value against reported ARR of roughly $480M growing above 20%. Call it 4.7x ARR, and roughly 81% below its 2021 financing. The same acquirer is taking Miro at $1.355B against a $17.5B late-2021 peak, a ~92% haircut. What those two share with July's worst Forge Price decliners (Airtable at −24.5%, Postman at −24.9%, Tanium at −12.8%) is the absence of a 2026 primary round.
Strong operating metrics do not defend a 2021 mark. A half-billion-dollar revenue business growing above 20% cleared at under 5x ARR.
Set that against CNBC's June count of 220-plus former unicorns now valued below $1B, 75 of them software companies, and the diligence problem gets concrete. Part of the tail discount is informational, a stale reference on a healthy business. Part of it is a worse business than the 2021 price implied. Current financials are the only thing that separates the two, and Airtable is the cost of guessing.
Where the two data sets disagree
The indicative and the completed diverge sharply this month, and the divergence is the actionable part. Forge Price is a model blending primary-round pricing, secondary transactions and non-binding indications of interest, with Forge disclosing it "may rely on a very limited number of trade and/or IOI inputs." The acquisition prints are contracts. A mark file that mixes both classes without labeling them gives an announcement the same weight as a signature, and this month the two pointed in opposite directions.
The liquidity math compounds it. Roughly $107B of direct secondaries traded in the twelve months to June, but the top 20 names accounted for 86% of Hiive's Q2 value, SpaceX went public in June, and PitchBook flags reduced forward flow from OpenAI and Anthropic. Anything outside the flagships fills slower from here.
What to do
Re-cut every secondary comp in the Q3 valuation pack on a vintage-adjusted basis before the committee date, segmenting 2026, 2025, 2022 and 2021 last-priced cohorts.
Require completed-trade evidence, or explicit disclosure that an input includes non-binding indications, before any model-derived indicative price enters a mark file or IC memo this quarter.
Re-underwrite SaaS exit assumptions against the Airtable and Miro clearing prices, and pre-brief LPs this quarter rather than letting the comps surface in the next letter.